Read REAL Super Nutrition Academy reviews from REAL members! CLICK HERE

  • Call now 1-888-529-9541
  • Help
  • Prefer to speak to someone?

    1-888-529-9541

    9am-5pm EST

    Monday-Fridays


  • Not a fan of the phone?

    Send us an email 


  • Need answers right away?

    Search our online FAQ 


Close
  • Home
  • Why SNA?
  • The Modules
  • Special Reports
  • About Yuri
  • Blog

Weight Loss and The Fallacy of 5-6 Meals Per Day

Posted: August 6th, 2013 @ 7:29 pm | By:
7 comments

Categories super nutrition academy health class



Episode #65

Want To Lose Weight?  Find Out The Truth About How To Eat To Lose Weight In This Episode




Click here to subscribe in iTunes (and download)

Weight LossWeight Loss

Does eating less or fewer meals help you lose weight? Welcome to this episode of the Super Nutrition Academy Health Class. Today I’m going to kind of be debunking another myth that has been very pervasive in our culture, which is, essentially, if you want to lose weight, you want to eat more often and more small meals to keep your metabolism fired up so that you can actually lose weight.

Well, today I’m going to kind of cut into that a little bit and give you some interesting insights and things to think about. Part of this was spurred on by a recent study that was presented at the American Diabetes Association, one of their conferences. Essentially, what this study looked at was, it was done in the Czech Republic, and they looked at 54 patients, so obviously not a huge sample size. These people had type 2 diabetes, and they followed them for 24 weeks.

What they did is they split the people in the study into two groups at random. Both groups followed a diet that reduced their energy intake by about 500 calories per day—that’s a pretty good kind of starting point—and contained 50ish percent carbohydrates, 20 to 25 percent protein, and less than 30 percent fat. The typical kind of Canada Food Guide or American Food Pyramid type of recommendations.

For the first 12 weeks, one group ate three main meals—breakfast, lunch, and dinner—and three small snacks in between those meals. Six times a day. The other group ate a large breakfast between 6 and 10 a.m. and a large lunch between noon and 4 p.m. and that’s it. The two groups then switched for the second 12 weeks. They were asked not to change their exercise habits during this study time.

The results showed that both groups lost weight and decreased the amount of fat in their livers, which is good. However, the group that was eating only two larger meals per day lost more weight during each 12-week session. Interesting. Eating fewer, bigger meals also led to lower fasting blood sugar levels, meaning that the body’s insulin production was working more efficiently. Hmm, very interesting.

Now, what’s funny about this is that different experts have kind of chimed in about this study, and one of the experts from CNN talked about the fact that she didn’t think that this is really livable for most people. We can’t just survive on two meals a day because most of us, for whatever reason, can’t skip dinner, God forbid. And then she goes on to say that eating several times a day might be beneficial for controlling calories and boosting our metabolism; the typical nonsense that we often hear.

Here’s where I really want to give you some a-ha moments. If you’re not one of our Super Nutrition Academy students, if you join the Academy, in addition to everything else you’re going to learn, Module 6, where we talk about metabolism and weight loss, will blow your mind. There is some stuff in there you will learn and discover that you’ve never even heard of.

And it’s not just my opinion; this is completely backed by science, as well as physiological foundation for how the body works. Really, what this comes down to, guys, is physics. I’m going to just give you a snippet of what I mean by that.

weight lossCalorie Intake For Weightloss

Okay, first of all, let’s look at how—okay, first of all, what is metabolism? Metabolism is the umbrella term which refers to all the processes in the body; anabolic and catabolic. Metabolism is the difference between anabolism and catabolism. Anabolism is building; catabolism is breaking down. Metabolism equals anabolism minus catabolism.

The aggregate of all the breaking down or all the building up in the body, that’s all metabolism is. Most people get metabolism confused with metabolic rate. Metabolic rate is essentially how much energy you’re expending per day, more or less.

Here’s some interesting stuff to consider. Let me ask you a question here. Let’s say we’ve got two people, and they’ve got the same activity level; there’s no difference in activity level. One person weighs 300 pounds; the other person weighs 150 pounds. Who has the higher metabolic rate?

Now, you may have said the person who weighs less, because we’ve all been led to believe that you’re skinny; you must have a high metabolism. Blah, blah, blah, blah. You can eat whatever you want. That’s complete and utter nonsense, and it’s so simple to understand once you understand this.

Okay, the person who weighs more, everything else being equal, will have a higher metabolic rate, and that sounds completely opposite to what you’ve ever heard. But here’s why this works. Metabolic rate is essentially, it’s a measure of how many calories we burn per day. It’s a measure of how much energy we expend. This is where the physics comes in.

Physics, if you remember if you took this in high school at any point, you probably learned the equation work = force x displacement. Work is simply another word for energy expenditure or calories burned. You can think about it that way.

If you’re not lifting any weight and let’s say you’re walking up a flight of stairs. The person who weighs 300 pounds requires more force because they have 300 pounds to move versus the 150-pounder. Let’s say they’re moving the same distance. Who’s going to do more work? The person who weighs 300 pounds. That’s right, because if we do force times displacement.

Force, let’s just say 300 pounds times 10 feet of stairs, we get 3000. I’m not going to go into the units ’cause you don’t need to know that, but let’s just use the numbers. The person who weighs 150 climbing up 10 feet of stairs is 150 times 10, so 1500. That’s literally as simple as it is when it comes down to metabolism and metabolic rate.

The biggest fallacy, other than that, we’ve been led to believe that eating more often is very important to keep our metabolic rate boosted per day. What accounts for the majority of it, 70 percent? Your resting metabolic rate; your basal metabolic rate.

So, instead of focusing on things to improve our basal metabolic rate, like lean body mass, reducing body fat and stuff, we’re so focused on how often we should be eating food, which is such a small portion of the equation.

Here’s the interesting thing. If you think about this, what’s one of the big problems in today’s society? Blood sugar, insulin levels, diabetes, obesity. It’s all related to the same thing, okay? When you eat six meals a day, here’s essentially what happens.

Let’s say you wake up at 7 a.m.; you have breakfast. God forbid you should go a couple hours without eating because your internal fireplace might dwindle. So, you have something a couple hours later for snack. Then you have lunch, then you have another snack. Then you have dinner, then you have a snack at night.

You’re not giving your hormones or your body any time to be in a fasted state. If you have breakfast at seven, then you get to work and let’s say it’s nine-thirty, then you’re having a snack, your body, depending on what you had for breakfast, has very little time to finish digesting that food. Or if it has digested that food, it has very little time to stay in a fasted state. Why is that a problem?

Well, here’s the problem. Insulin is only released in a fed state, so if you want constantly high insulin levels, keep eating all day long. You can graze all you like; you can eat small portions of this and that all day long, but just understand this: When you eat, insulin is released.

Because insulin, its role is to take elevated blood sugar, bring it back down to normal by taking sugar in the blood and storing it. The more often you eat, the more often insulin will be circulating in your blood, and that’s a problem because the more often insulin circulates in your blood, the more exposure it has to your cells; and the more often insulin’s exposed to your cells, the quicker they’ll become resistant to insulin.

Do you see how this works? You can eat five, six times a day all you want. It’s not going to make a difference, and I guarantee in the long run, it’s going to do way more harm to you than good. That’s why this study I found really interesting, because they showed that with just two meals a day. You’re not starving yourself by eating twice a day. You’re doing your body a ton of favors.

I may have talked about this before. If you follow any of my stuff or if you’re part of the academy, you know the benefits of spending more time in a fasted state is essential to living longer, to having healthier hormone profiles, to having healthier blood sugar levels, to everything.

weight lossHow To Eat To Lose Weight

But we’re so concerned about eating every two to three hours, it’s ridiculous. We’ve been fed so many lies. If we were to count up all the lies we’ve been led to believe…this would be one of the big ones. And, obviously, some of these lies I discuss in the “Big, Fat Food Lies” report over at the SuperNutritionAcademy.com site, which you can grab for free if you haven done so already. But this is definitely one of the big ones.

And I think it’s doing a lot of damage more so than good, because we’ve led to believe that if you don’t eat, oh my God, it’s not good to be in a fasted state because if you’re in a fasted state, you’re going to ruin your metabolism. Whoa, your body’s going to go into this starvation mode because it hasn’t eaten for, like, five hours. Therefore, you’re going to store all this fat, and everything you eat afterward is going to be stored as fat. It’s not true.

It’s true if you deprive yourself for several days on end, but if you think about going back to how our body has evolved, we are still operating as Paleolithic men biologically. We have not changed. We’ve been on this planet for such, a blink of an eye in respect to evolution that we are, in our modern society, still on the biology of Paleolithic man.

Paleolithic man did not have the luxury of eating whatever he wanted five to six times a day. Maybe sometimes he did, but not every single day, 365 days a year. There were days where there was no food, and they would go searching for food without any answers. That’s essentially a one-day fast. That fast may have prolonged for several days. In some cases they would find food, hunt it, and then they would have plentiful amounts of food for a day or a couple of days.

That’s how our body has evolved, and that’s the current biology we’re still working with. Our body is naturally best equipped to go through periods of fed and fasted states; not necessarily for weeks on end, but for a couple days at the very most, at least for a day, try not eating any food. You’ll feel more mentally clear. Sure, you’re going to go through some hunger pangs; you’ll go through some emotional distraught.

It’s actually very interesting to go through that process because you’ll learn a lot about why you crave certain foods. A lot of it is conditioning and habit.

The message I want to get across in this episode is that eating five, six, seven meals a day, however many meals, is not the answer to losing weight. It’s the answer to keeping your insulin levels excessively high over time to eventually causing problems down the road with blood sugar, leading to diabetes and obesity and other problems.

I really firmly believe this, and that’s why I’m a huge proponent of eating less and listening to when your body is hungry. Who says that breakfast is the most important meal of the day? Who says, some scientific studies? Well, some scientific studies will show that maybe a late lunch is the best meal of the day.

What if you wake up in the morning and you’re not hungry? Why should you be forced to eat a meal first thing in the morning, when you just get out of bed? If you’re not hungry, listen to your body. Listen to your body, not the latest scientific study that was done on other people. That is what you need to pay attention to: your body, what your body is telling you.

You go to bed at ten o’clock at night, you wake up at eight in the morning or seven in the morning or six in the morning, you’ve just done a fast. You’ve just done an eight-hour fast, let’s say. What does breakfast mean? If we break down breakfast, it’s “break the fast.” Break fast.

But that breakfast, in a lot of studies, includes the cream and sugar that was added to a morning coffee. In some studies that constitutes breakfast. There’s a huge disparity amongst studies and what they’re looking at and what they’re deeming as breakfast.

A lot of times I don’t eat breakfast. I’ll go until lunch without eating anything, so I’ve just done a 16- to 18-hour fast. And then some days I’ll wake up and I’m hungry and I’ll have breakfast then. You have to listen to your body.

Don’t worry about the five-to-six-meals-a-day nonsense. It’s one of the biggest lies out there, and I hope this information has helped you realize that. Again, I discuss this in way more detail in Module 6 of Super Nutrition Academy, as well as some of the later modules where we talk about fasting and life extension and some really awesome stuff.

If you haven’t already done so, you can try the Academy for just a dollar. I believe it’s so powerful for you to have this information that we literally want to give it to you for free to try out for 30 days. At that point you can decide if it’s for you. If it’s not, then, again, you can cancel at any point. It’s just our way of really getting this information to more and more people, because we need to know this stuff; we need to get away from the lies and the nonsense and all of this misinformation and confusion.

I want to thank you for joining me once again. Hop over to SuperNutritionAcademy.com, join us today. Your life will change for the better, I promise you. And I look forward to seeing you in the next episode.

Related Posts:
Is Coffee Good For You? (The TRUTH)
Dangerous Low Carb Advice with Abel James
Are You Really Eating As Healthy As You Think? (with Lori Kennedy)
What Foods Are Good For Your Skin? (Answers Inside)

Tags: calorie intake for weight loss, how to eat to lose weight, weight loss

About Super Nutrition Academy

Super Nutrition Academy is the ONLY nutrition course that makes it easy for everyday people to understand the complex relationship between nutrition and health. If you're tired of all the conflicting health information out there and want a clear-cut, evidence-based understanding of the nutrition and health topics that matter you, then get started today.

 

SNA Quiz - Test Your Knowledge

 


Leave A Reply (7 comments So Far)

  1. harkishan

    i am fan of your all articles but my only difficulty is that i am a senior citizen and no job since last 7 years. i try to maintain myself on meger ssi of$600.00. so i can not afford a;;the costs. i hope you will understand my difficulty.thanks.wish you all the best.

     
  2. Amy

    I think this is true for the average person who tends to eat on the higher side of the glycemic scale, but what about those who don’t? Those people who eat high fiber, high protein, low carb, gluten free- would they not have a lower insulin response after every meal?

    Further, what is an appropriate fasting time to not elicit a cortisol response? I would think after 18-20 hours, cortisol would be elevated, defeating the purpose of fasting.

     
    • YuriElkaim

      they would but they’ll still not giving their body a rest from chronic insulin. 18-24 hours is fine for a fast.

       
  3. Des

    I like and agree with most of this article. I believe that two meals a day is perfect, providing the circumstances allow it. Because of our school and work program we have opted for three meals a day.
    6:30am – Porridge (cooked) with a banana, a table spoon each of molasses, moringa and boabab fruit powder, no dairy and no sugar. Occasionally avocado in the porridge. Soon we will have our own honey so a teaspoon of that will be added.
    My children (26 Orphans & abandoned) have difficulty with school break when they are ridiculed because of their lack of something to eat. Children can be so cruel. So we compromised and have given them a popped corn (maputi). It is popped maize without oil and salt. The salt is added afterwards.
    Our three meal a day plus one unfortunate snack:
    10:00 School break and Maputi
    1:30 pm – Stiff maize porridge (sadza) with vegetables and tomato.
    7:00pm – Fortified brown rice. I’m a little worried about this as it comes ready to cook from the USA which might mean it is GMO. This I certainly do not want, so we are making inquires as to it’s origin..
    I’d love to join your academy but am not able to pay because my clinic serves the very poor. The money we get in is not enough to pay salaries so we are all volunteers or currently there are two social work students on attachment.
    We also have difficulty in transferring money out of the country (Zimbabwe).
    The main differences between us is your belief in evolution and my belief in creation and, of course, your superior knowledge in nutrition.
    I am 72 and I want to learn as much as I can so that I can serve the community better.
    Des

     
  4. Bonnie

    Yuri…I’m all for helping out Des. God blesses those who give back. I vote you honor Des’s work by allowing a free membership. Bless you Des and everyone who helps others. I too am struggling on my income and do the best that I can. God bless you Yuri and Des…Not to leave out harkishan and Amy! I hope we all keep up the strength to take care of ourselves and those who need our help.

     
  5. Sarah Almond

    Thank you once again Yuri, the work you do is invaluable and it’s great that you get straight to the point and don’t beat around the bush. Keep up the good work!

     
  6. Emy

    How to get rid off saggy belly?

     
Get your FREE Report
BIG FAT FOOD LIES

Available for a limited time only!






  • Popular
  • Latest
  • Comments
    • The Food Babe Way with Vani Hari Episode #113 The Food Babe Way with Vani Hari Click here to subscribe in iTunes (and download) The Food...
    • Are Raw Cruciferous Vegetables Hurting Your Thyroid? Episode #112 Discover whether kale, broccoli, and other cruciferous are hurting your thyroid. Click here to subscribe...
    • 10 Fat Habits Destroying Your Diet Episode #111 Discover the 10 fat habits that could be destroying you diet. Click here to subscribe...
    • Day Detox Diet with Dr. Mark Hyman Episode #110 Learn how to eradicate sugar cravings and lose weight in just 10 days time...
    • Environment vs. Willpower - Which is More Powerful for Building Good Habits? Episode #109 For years we've been led to believe that building habits is a matter of...

      Available for a limited time only!





      • Super Nutrition Academy

        • Home
        • About
        • The Modules
        • Special Reports
        • Reviews
        • Enroll Now
      • Get Informed

        • Blog
        • Test Your Knowledge
        • SNA Health Class on iTunes
        •  
        •  
        •  
      • Support and Community

        • Student Login
        • Customer Support
        • FAQs
        • Yuri Elkaim on Facebook
        • Yuri Elkaim on Google +
        •  
        •  
        •  
        •  
        •  
        •  
        •  

      © Total Wellness Consulting, Inc. | 460 West Hunt Club Road, Suite 206 Ottawa, Ontario K2E 0B8
      All rights reserved

      Terms of Use    |    Privacy Policy    |    Affiliates    |    Contact Us